Where can I find information on a board's legal duties?


Legal duties

The board acts as trustee of the organization's assets and ensures that the nonprofit is well managed and remains fiscally sound. In doing so, the board must exercise proper oversight of the organization's operations and maintain the legal and ethical accountability of its staff and volunteers.

The main legal responsibilities of a nonprofit board are often summarized in the "three Ds":

  • Duty of care: Board members are expected to actively participate in organizational planning and decision-making and to make sound and informed judgments.
  • Duty of loyalty: When acting on behalf of the organization, board members must put the interests of the nonprofit before any personal or professional concerns and avoid potential conflicts of interest.
  • Duty of obedience: Board members must ensure that the organization complies with all applicable federal, state, and local laws and regulations, and that it remains committed to its established mission.

In addition to its legal responsibilities, the board acts in a fiduciary role by maintaining oversight of the nonprofit's finances. Board members must evaluate financial policies, approve annual budgets, and review periodic financial reports to ensure that the organization has the necessary resources to carry out its mission and remains accountable to its donors and the general public. The board must also ensure compliance with federal and state regulations.

To learn more about developing a board for a newer organization, please see our free recorded webinars or tutorials:

 

Meeting Minutes

Meeting minutes are legal records, so it's important to get them right.

In essence, the minutes describe when your nonprofit's meeting was, where it was, who was there, any actions members took and what's ahead. Effective minutes help board members focus and keep track of their work.

Form 990 also asks whether nonprofits "contemporaneously document" board actions. Answering "no" suggests poor management and might make your organization subject to an IRS audit.

Staff-recommended resources at the bottom of this page include templates for keeping minutes for your nonprofit's meetings.

For an in-depth guide, see Anthony Mancuso's Nonprofit Meetings, Minutes & Records: How to Properly Document Your Nonprofit's Actions. Also, chapter 15 of The Handbook of Nonprofit Governance by BoardSource has information about board minutes.

 

Advisory boards

Advisory boards or committees are volunteer groups formed to give advice and support to a nonprofit's governing board or executive staff.

Unlike a governing board, an advisory board does not have any formal legal responsibilities or decision-making authority. Nonetheless, advisory boards can be helpful for purposes of fundraising, gathering advice on specific programs, or providing leadership opportunities for key individuals who may not have the capacity to serve on an organization's governing board.

To learn more about advisory boards, check out the staff-recommended resources list at the bottom of this page.

 

Executive transitions

One of the most important responsibilities for nonprofit boards is selecting the organization's next executive director. The search and transition can be complex, and both generally require careful planning, well before a planned - or unplanned - departure occurs.

This process, also known as succession planning, includes developing your staff's knowledge, skills, and abilities, and preparing for the many changes that come with a change in leadership. Some things to consider, for example:

  • What does the board need to do during the first five days after the initial announcement?
  • Will you need a temporary chief executive?
  • Have you developed a transition timeline?
  • What do you need to include in the new chief executive's orientation packet?

The Annie E. Casey Foundation argues that nonprofits should have a succession plan because it: Ensures the organization's viability in the event of a key manager's unplanned absence

  • Makes the organization more nimble and flexible by developing a deep talent pool
  • Makes the executive's job more "doable" because leadership is shared
  • Energizes and reassures the board by providing opportunities to develop high-level strategies for the future
  • Strengthens the local nonprofit network as staff develop their skills and ambitions

 

See also our related Knowledge Base articles:

Back to the top

 

13 Meeting Minutes Templates to Help You Ace Your Nonprofit Board Meeting
Wild Apricot

This blog has a bullet list of standard contents in meeting minutes, plus links to formatted templates. It also offers a free downloadable tool, "The Ultimate Meeting Minute Checklist."

Taking Board Meeting Minutes
Charities Review Council

Includes a checklist, mistakes to avoid, and a template.

How to Take Minutes at a Board Meeting
BoardEffect

This step-by-step blog post from a board consulting firm links to a free meeting minutes kit.

Board Member Contract
Blue Avocado

A sample contract for board members. It outlines explicitly what is expected of individual board members, and how the organization will in turn be responsible to them.

What are the legal responsibilities of nonprofit boards?
BoardSource

Describes the three main legal duties of nonprofit boards – duty of care, duty of loyalty, and duty of obedience. This site also includes downloadable BoardSource guides, tools, templates and infographics

Governance and Related Topics - 501(c)(3) Organizations
IRS

IRS's recommended policies and practices for nonprofit governance, especially in regards to: Mission; Organizational Documents; Governing Body; Governance and Management Policies; Financial Statements and Form 990 Reporting; and Transparency and Accountability.

What to Do When You Really, Really Disagree with a Board Decision
Blue Avocado

"There are more choices than simply keeping quiet or being disruptive...." Jan Masaoka's blog posted Feb. 22, 2010.

Preventing and Investigating Fraud, Embezzlement, and Charitable Asset Diversion: What's a Nonprofit Board to Do?
Venable LLP

A lengthy, detailed guide to investigating or preventing fraud or embezzlement in a nonprofit. Written by a lawyer with a lot of nonprofit experience.

Free Complete Toolkit for Boards

The Free Management Library contains links and resources on a variety of topics related to organizational management for both for-profit and nonprofit organizations. The site includes a section on legal and ethical responsibilities of boards.

Succession Planning for Nonprofits of All Sizes
Blue Avocado

Succession should be a topic taken up now, whether or not you expect a change in executives. Includes questions and issues to be addressed now, and some that draw attention to longer-term planning. Increase your readiness for this inevitable occurrence and the likelihood of a positive transition.

Sample Succession Plan
Association of Baltimore Area Grantmakers

This document outlines a leadership development and emergency succession plan in the event of a planned or unplanned temporary or short-term absence.

Advisory Board Best Practices: Roles, Responsibilities, and Advice

Explores the roles of advisory boards and best practices.

How to Form a Nonprofit Advisory Board
Authenticity Consulting LLC

Offers a definition of an advisory board and provides guidance on structuring the group.

Guidelines to Form an Advisory Group
Free Management Library

Provides a broad overview on why and how to form an advisory committee.

Advisory Boards and Other Bodies: Yes or No and Why or Why Not?
Nonprofit Quarterly

Provides guidance on when an advisory board may be appropriate for a nonprofit.

Advisory Board v. Board of Directors - A Distinction with a Difference
Nonprofit Law Blog

Explains the legal and structural differences between an advisory board and board of directors in a nonprofit.

What is an Advisory Board and Should We Have One?
Blue Avocado

This article explains what an advisory board is, what the different types are, and the guidelines for setting up an advisory board.

BoardSource

BoardSource (formerly the National Center for Nonprofit Boards) provides an excellent selection of board resources for both members and non-members. Hover over the word "Topics" to find the resource library.